Back
education-15-01069-v3
Journal article

Reflections on How Adults Respond to Children’s Contributions in Children–Adult Argumentative Interactions

  • 2025
Published in:
  • Education sciences. - 2025, vol. 15, no. 8
children-adult argumentation
subdiscussion
discussion space
adult’s response
dialogic interactions
English This paper aims to analyze adults’ responses to children’s argumentative contributions within children–adult dialogic interactions. More precisely, we focus on the phenomenon of children opening subdiscussions within argumentative interactions with peers and adults. This phenomenon occurs when a child problematizes and calls into question some proposition in the ongoing discussion, hence the opening of a subdiscussion is an initiative that comes as unexpected from the perspective of the adult. In this contribution, we examine what happens after a child opens a subdiscussion and how the adult’s reaction to such initiatives can shape the development of dialogue. This means that we observe adult behaviour in dialogic interactions with children, given the complexity of the adult’s role in such interactions. Drawing on the dialogical approach to argumentation, we present and discuss some excerpts of children–adult subdiscussions at a kindergarten. The data analysis uses concepts and tools from a linguistics-based approach to argumentation, i.e., the pragma-dialectical theory, and it highlights conversational dynamics of children–adult argumentative discourse. The study’s contribution is twofold: (1) it presents the important and delicate role of the adult in dialogic children–adult interactions; (2) it shows how the development of children’s arguments is intrinsically linked to the flexibility of the discussion space organized by the adult.
Language
  • English
Classification
Education, teaching
Other electronic version

Version publiée

License
CC BY
Open access status
gold
Identifiers
Persistent URL
https://roar.hep-bejune.ch/hepbejune/documents/332803
Statistics
Document views: 1 File downloads:
  • education-15-01069-v3.pdf: 0